Which rewards card earns the most on the way you spend? Points Frog's best credit card calculator answers with plain arithmetic. It takes what you spend each month in six categories, applies each card's earn rates, values the points and subtracts the annual fee. Then it ranks 14 popular cards by what is left.
On average US spending of $2,832 a month, the calculator puts the Capital One Venture on top at $1,128 a year after its $95 fee. The Amex Gold Card is next at $1,082. The best card with no annual fee is the Wells Fargo Autograph, at $856. Earn rates and fees come from each issuer's own card page, checked October 18, 2026.
The example household
The calculator starts with a household that spends $329 a month on dining, $519 on groceries, $207 on travel, $201 on gas, $76 on streaming and $1,500 on everything else. The food, gas and travel figures are US household averages from the BLS report Consumer Expenditures in 2024, released December 19, 2025. Streaming is the average from the Deloitte Digital Media Monitor, updated October 15, 2026. The $1,500 of everything else is an assumption.
Here is how the top card gets its number. The Venture earns 2 miles a dollar in every category. A year of spending, $33,984, earns 67,968 miles. At Points Frog's value of 1.8 cents a mile, that is $1,223, or 3.6% back. Take off the $95 fee and the net is $1,128.
| Card | Rewards a year | Fee | Net a year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Capital One Venture | $1,223 | $95 | $1,128 |
| Amex Gold Card | $1,407 | $325 | $1,082 |
| Citi Strata Premier | $1,122 | $95 | $1,027 |
| Chase Sapphire Preferred | $1,020 | $95 | $925 |
| Wells Fargo Autograph | $856 | $0 | $856 |
| Chase Sapphire Reserve | $987 | $795 | $192 |
| Amex Platinum Card | $818 | $895 | −$77 |
The Amex Gold earns the most before fees, $1,407, but its $325 fee drops it to second. At the bottom of the list, the Amex Platinum loses $77 a year on spending alone.
What moves the ranking
Where the money goes matters most. The page tests this by starting from the average household and changing one thing at a time. With $1,000 a month on dining, the Amex Gold leads at $1,758 a year. With a $1,200 grocery bill, it leads at $1,768. A frequent traveler who spends $1,000 a month on flights and hotels sees the Citi Strata Premier on top at $1,527. A light spender at $1,000 a month in total sees the Venture at $337 and the no-fee Citi Double Cash at $294.
Point values come next. A rate in points is worth the points times the value of each one, so 4x at 2 cents a point is 8 cents back per dollar. Points Frog values Membership Rewards points at 2.1 cents, Ultimate Rewards points at 2 cents, Capital One miles at 1.8 cents, ThankYou points at 1.75 cents and Wells Fargo Rewards points at 1.6 cents. Cash back counts at 1 cent. Points you cash out or trade for gift cards are usually worth less than these estimates.
Spending caps count too. The Amex Gold's 4x on groceries applies to the first $25,000 a year, then drops to 1x. The Blue Cash Preferred pays 6% on groceries up to $6,000 a year, then 1%. Past a cap, the calculator uses the lower rate.
Annual fees decide the rest. At average spending, 4 of the 8 cards with a fee beat the best no-fee card after paying it.
What the calculator leaves out
The ranking covers what a card earns year after year. It leaves out welcome offers, statement credits, anniversary bonuses, foreign transaction fees and higher rates for booking through a card's own travel site. Premium cards make up some of their fees with travel credits and lounge access. Those are worth something only if you would use them anyway.
It compares one card at a time, so a pair of cards can earn more than its top pick. Co-branded airline and hotel cards are not included. The Citi Double Cash counts at 70% of the ThankYou value, because on its own it transfers to partners at 1,000 points to 700 miles. It never counts below the 1 cent its points are worth as cash.
The page has no affiliate links, and the ranking is only the arithmetic. It is an educational estimate. Approval depends on your credit, and carrying a balance costs far more in interest than any card earns in rewards.
Where the figures come from
Earn rates and fees are from Chase, American Express, Capital One, Citi and Wells Fargo, each checked October 18, 2026. Point values are from Points Frog's point value catalog, where the current figures carry the date October 13, 2026. Spending averages are from the BLS and Deloitte, as dated above.
Use it on your own site
The calculator is free to embed on a blog or site with copy-and-paste code, with no ads or tracking. Here is how to embed it.
Source: BLS, Consumer Expenditures in 2024, December 19, 2025; Deloitte Digital Media Monitor, October 15, 2026; issuer card pages, checked October 18, 2026. Figures are educational estimates, not financial advice.