What's the best credit card for my spending?
For a household with average US spending, about $2,832 a month on a card, the Capital One Venture earns the most: $1,128 a year after its $95 annual fee, or 3.6% back before the fee. The Amex Gold Card is next at $1,082. The best card with no annual fee is the Wells Fargo Autograph, at $856 a year. Which card wins for you depends on where your money goes, so enter your own spending above.
| Card | Rewards | Fee | Net a year |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Capital One Venture | $1,223 | $95 | $1,128 |
| 2. Amex Gold Card | $1,407 | $325 | $1,082 |
| 3. Citi Strata Premier | $1,122 | $95 | $1,027 |
| 4. Chase Sapphire Preferred | $1,020 | $95 | $925 |
| 5. Wells Fargo Autograph | $856 | $0 | $856 |
| 6. Citi Double Cash | $833 | $0 | $833 |
| 7. Capital One Venture X | $1,223 | $395 | $828 |
| 8. Wells Fargo Active Cash | $680 | $0 | $680 |
| 9. Amex Blue Cash Preferred | $734 | $95 | $639 |
| 10. Chase Freedom Unlimited | $569 | $0 | $569 |
| 11. Capital One Savor | $562 | $0 | $562 |
| 12. Amex Blue Cash Everyday | $508 | $0 | $508 |
| 13. Chase Sapphire Reserve | $987 | $795 | $192 |
| 14. Amex Platinum Card | $818 | $895 | −$77 |
Which credit card earns the most in each spending category?
Valued at Points Frog's estimates, the richest rates are dining: the Amex Gold Card (8.4¢ per dollar); groceries: the Amex Gold Card (8.4¢ per dollar); travel: the Chase Sapphire Reserve (8¢ per dollar); gas: the Chase Sapphire Preferred (6¢ per dollar); streaming: the Chase Sapphire Preferred (6¢ per dollar); everything else: the Capital One Venture (3.6¢ per dollar). A rate in points is worth the points times what each point is worth, so 4x at 2 cents a point is 8 cents back per dollar.
| Category | Card | Back per dollar |
|---|---|---|
| Dining | Amex Gold Card | 8.4¢ |
| Groceries | Amex Gold Card | 8.4¢ |
| Travel | Chase Sapphire Reserve | 8¢ |
| Gas | Chase Sapphire Preferred | 6¢ |
| Streaming | Chase Sapphire Preferred | 6¢ |
| Everything else | Capital One Venture | 3.6¢ |
Which card is best for different spenders?
The same cards rank differently as spending shifts. Each row below starts from the average household and changes one thing.
| Spending | Earns the most | Best with no fee |
|---|---|---|
| Average householdUS averages for food, gas, travel and streaming | Capital One Venture, $1,128 | Wells Fargo Autograph, $856 |
| Eats out a lot$1,000 a month on dining | Amex Gold Card, $1,758 | Wells Fargo Autograph, $1,242 |
| Big grocery bill$1,200 a month on groceries | Amex Gold Card, $1,768 | Citi Double Cash, $1,033 |
| Frequent traveler$1,000 a month on flights and hotels | Citi Strata Premier, $1,527 | Wells Fargo Autograph, $1,313 |
| Long commute$500 a month on gas | Capital One Venture, $1,258 | Wells Fargo Autograph, $1,028 |
| Light spender$1,000 a month, mostly everyday purchases | Capital One Venture, $337 | Citi Double Cash, $294 |
Is a credit card with an annual fee worth it?
Only if its extra rewards beat a no-fee card by more than the fee. At average spending, 4 of the 8 cards with a fee come out ahead of the best no-fee card (the Wells Fargo Autograph, $856 a year) after paying it, and the Amex Platinum Card loses $77 a year on spending alone. Premium cards make up the difference with travel credits, lounge access and other perks this calculator doesn't count, which are worth it only if you'd use them anyway.
How the calculator works
- Each category's monthly spending is multiplied by 12 and by the card's earn rate there, in points or percent back per dollar.
- Points are valued at Points Frog's estimates for each rewards currency, mostly what they get transferred to airline and hotel partners. Cash back, and points a card can only cash out, count at 1 cent each.
- Net value is a year of rewards minus the annual fee. Cards are ranked by it.
- Spending caps are applied: past a yearly cap, spending in that category earns the card's lower rate.
- Travel means flights and hotels booked directly with the airline or hotel; where a card pays differently on the two, travel counts as half each. Higher rates for booking through a card's own travel site are left out, and so are welcome offers, statement credits, anniversary bonuses and foreign transaction fees.
- Co-branded airline and hotel cards are left out, since their best rates are on that one airline or hotel chain.